Sales Tax and the Free Rider Problem
Economists talk about the Free Rider Problem with reference to common resources — things that benefit everyone. An example might be roads, hospitals, schools, public parks, and many other things that can be funded at least in part by sales tax. In theory, everyone uses these resources, and everyone pays for them, so there’s no problem. The Free Rider Problem comes up when someone uses more of the resources than their part of the cost pays for, or uses the resources without paying at all. It’s no problem at first. If ten people pay sales taxes that cover the cost of a park and eleven people use the park, there is no negative effect for the ten who paid.
Everyone benefits from the park, and the people who pay are not affected by the extra person’s use of the park. If ten people pay taxes for the park and 50 people use it, though, the people who pay will soon find that
their park is crowded, filled with rubbish, and generally not being cared for, because the resources they’ve pooled aren’t enough to cover the needs of so many people. When it comes to sales tax, the Free Rider Problem often comes up in decision making. Missouri is currently debating a sales tax to pay for roads. For many people, a gas tax for roads makes sense, since drivers pay the tax and drivers use the roads. Those who hold this viewpoint feel that a sales tax makes people who don’t drive pay more for their TV sets, and creates a Free Rider Problem for those whose casual shopping is funding the roads for truckers and bus drivers. Are they right?
First, let’s consider the idea that people who shop aren’t necessarily using the roads. On the surface, it may seem that people who shop and people who use roads are two different sets. Look more closely, and you’ll see that the goods those shoppers buy came to the shop on roads. The people who sell the goods came to work on roads. The teachers who taught the cashiers the math they need to sell the goods (or the computer skills) used the roads to get to the schools. The materials that built the store were brought by road, and so were the vehicles used in construction. The corporations that decided to build the store in this location used information about the neighborhood’s infrastructure to make that decision. It doesn’t matter how deeply we delve into the scenario: the roads are involved. In the very interconnected system of modern retail, it’s ludicrous to suggest that shopping is not connected with road transport.
However, there’s another question. The Free Rider Problem isn’t really about fairness. It’s about the idea that people who don’t pay for what they use create burdens that can’t be supported both those who do pay. For road taxes, that can mean that more people drive, if gas taxes don’t discourage extra driving. It can mean that the roads are more congested, deteriorate faster, and are less safe than they would be if the coasts of maintaining the road were more closely tied to the amount of money drivers could furnish through gas taxes. Finally, we have to acknowledge that tax costs aren’t as closely tied with their benefits as the Free Rider Problem implies. Jurisdictions with lower sales taxes usually have higher income taxes or property taxes. A certain amount of money is needed for public resources, and states generally do whatever they can to find the money they need. Whatever the economics of sales tax, you still need a great automated method for calculating and filing your sales and use taxes. Sales Tax DataLINK’s suite of sales and use tax tools leverage patented technology to make your filing faster, easier, and more accurate
National Sales Tax The idea of a national sales tax has once again been introduced as a bill in Congress. The Fair Tax Act of 2023 is currently being considered in the House. This bill would, if passed, abolish the Internal Revenue Service, repeal...
Sin tax A sin tax is a type of sales tax intended to discourage people from buying a particular item. An extra tax on the purchase of cigarettes, soda, or alcohol may be intended to keep consumers from buying as much if these sinful items -- oral least...
The GAO speaks up on remote seller sales taxes The Government Accountability Office is responsible for providing important facts to Congress so they can make the best legislative decisions. They have just released a report on the question of sales tax...