Online Sales Tax: Is It about Fairness?

Most purchases take place in stores. Physical stores where people can touch, try out, and perhaps taste or smell the items they’re buying. Internet shopping is increasing, though, along with hybrid forms of purchasing like online orders for physical delivery or pickup. Right now, you can order a birthday cake for your friend in another state and have it delivered right there in the state by your friend’s local bakery, and the bakery usually will not have to collect sales tax. You would still be required to pay sales and use taxes, but the truth is that most people don’t keep track of their online purchases or make any effort to pay the tax on them. This issue is often presented as a question of fairness.

Local businesses, we’re told, have to collect sales tax. This gives online sellers an advantage over their local small businesses. People order from ecommerce sites like Amazon, the argument goes, in order to save the cost of sales tax. This puts local businesses at a disadvantage. Does it? Estimates suggest that 70% of ecommerce transactions are already taxed in most states. People shop with companies which have stores in their states, from big box stores like Target and Walmart to specialty chains like Pottery Barn and Sephora. They also shop with small merchants who would be exempt from laws like the Marketplace Fairness Act anyway. What’s more, local businesses increasingly participate in ecommerce themselves. Nothing changes a brick and mortar merchant’s mind about online sales tax faster than learning what he’ll have to do to comply with requirements to collect sales tax in multiple jurisdictions.

As we’ve pointed out before, the states are not trying to impose sales tax out of an altruistic desire to support Main Street. States are hurting for sales tax revenue, not just because more people are shopping online but because consumers are nervous and spending more cautiously. Naturally, seeing that ecommerce sales reached an estimated $263.3 billion in 2013 makes states wish they were receiving the sales tax on those transactions. Will remote sellers be held accountable for collecting sales tax? It’s likely that at some point they will. The constitution requires that there be no “undue burden” on interstate commerce. The object of the requirement was to make sure that no state could make protectionist rulings against other states. At the time, states that had seaports had great economic advantages over those that did not.

The ability of those states to benefit from this advantage at the expense of neighboring states created intense rivalries that threatened the unity of the nation. That isn’t relevant to Amazon. It might be time for sweeping sales tax reforms that recognize the changes in the world we live in, as some have suggested. It might be time for states to get creative about raising revenue. Whichever direction the government takes, buyers and sellers alike will need to be on their toes. A web-based sales tax solution helps your company remain responsive and up to date, no matter which way the controversy goes.

Latest Articles

Senate Finance Committee Examines Wayfair Decision

Senate Finance Committee Examines Wayfair Decision

The Wayfair decision Four years ago, the Supreme Court's decision in South Dakota vs. Wayfair changed everything about sales tax compliance for businesses with revenue from multiple states. Instead of being responsible only for transactions in states...

read more
Do We Still Care about Physical Nexus?

Do We Still Care about Physical Nexus?

The new nexus Before the Supreme Court's decision in South Dakota vs. Wayfair, remote sellers only had to collect sales tax when they had a physical presence in a jurisdiction. A store, a warehouse full of your products, affiliate sellers -- these...

read more
Sales Tax and Barter

Sales Tax and Barter

a The Barter Life It used to be that businesses only had to collect and file sales taxes if they had a physical presence in a state: an office, a store, a warehouse, or a factory, for example. A small business using e-commerce to sell in other states or...

read more