How Post-Wayfair Sales Tax Laws Affect eBay

Devin Wenig, CEO of eBay, says his concerns about the new, post-Wayfair sales tax situation have turned out to be all too true. “One emerging challenge for our small business sellers in the US is the rapidly evolving landscape for internet sales tax,” he said in an earnings call. “At the start of the year, only a handful of states had active legislation requiring marketplaces to collect sales tax. By the end of the year, that number will grow to more than 30 states, and it’ll cover the majority of US GMV [gross merchandise volume].” 

CFO Scott Schenkel added, ” this is exactly what we said, which would happen, which is small US businesses are being disfavored, the impact is disproportionate… It’s favoring larger businesses and retailers and it’s also favoring international businesses. So, we again will call for a federal legislation on internet sales tax and a small business exemption. And I’ll say that you’ll continue to hear me say that because what we’re seeing is exactly what we had feared and what we had said.” 

EBay automatically calculates, collects, and remits sales taxes on behalf of its sellers. This is part of eBay’s role as a marketplace facilitator. EBay sellers are generally pleased that they don’t have to deal with the complexities of remote seller sales tax on their own. However, they don’t have the option of limiting which states they’ll sell to.

The result, according to Wenig, is a dip in sales. Overall, he says, sales are down by 1 percentage point. He attributes the change to the higher prices created by the new sales tax rules.

Are the new sales tax regulations a price hike?

No, the states will say. Buyers at eBay have always been required to pay use tax, the equivalent of sales tax, on their purchases. If an online merchant doesn’t collect sales tax, the consumer is supposed to calculate what he should have paid and add it to his income tax return.

Almost nobody does this.

That’s why eBay can describe the new tax collection as a price hike. Deciding that consumers are also seeing it as a price hike and blaming it for a 1% drop in sales in Q2? That’s more imaginative. EBay’s data set is large enough to provide data to work with, but connecting lower spending with sales tax may be too much of a leap. Data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis shows that consumer spending grew in Q2, with particularly robust increases in ecommerce and restaurant meals.

Outside of eBay

EBay takes care of sales tax compliance for its sellers. Who’s looking after other remote sellers? No one, really. From small to medium size online retailers to manufacturers who sell direct to consumer as well as wholesale, companies are getting frustrated.

  • In which states are your goods taxable? The definition of taxable items is different from one state to another. Just in the category of clothing, states determine taxability on the basis of price, use, where it’s bought, whether it has a protective purpose, material, and even what it’s worn with.
  • What’s the sales tax threshold? Many states exempt sellers with less than $100,000 in revenue. However, some states base the threshold on the number of transactions, which can cause companies to reach the threshold with much lower revenue. Some states also include a company’s total revenue, including wholesale as well as retail sales.
  • What’s the sales tax rate? Some states have a flat rate for remote sellers, but some allow cities and counties to add their rates to the state sales tax rate.

Multi-state sales tax compliance can be frustrating. Before you stress out enough to throw in the towel, let Sales Tax DataLINK help. You can outsource the entire process to our team of experts.

Latest Articles

Pennsylvania Celebrates Online Sales Tax

The Supreme Court decision known as Wayfair allowed states to force online sellers to collect and file sales taxes, even if they have no physical presence in the state. It's been a rocky road for some states, but Pennsylvania is feeling pretty good...

read more

Colorado Sales Tax Update

Colorado has had some challenges as the legislature tries to work out the details of sales tax for remote sellers. They actually had to back off and reschedule their changes. As of June 1, 2019, however, remote sellers with revenue from Colorado of...

read more