Gross Sales May Cause Sales Tax Surprises
States no longer have to limit their sales tax collection requirements to sellers with physical nexus in their state. Since the Supreme Court overturned Quill last summer, states can require companies to collect and pay sales tax because of “economic nexus” or “cookie nexus” if they feel like it.
Most states feel like it. As states add new sales tax regulations, though, something interesting is happening in some states. And it’s not interesting in a good way, either.
States are exempting companies that don’t reach a certain threshold in sales. $250,000 a year or 200 transactions, for example, is the threshold in Georgia. The average e-commerce basket size in the US is about $82.00. So an e-commerce seller who does 200 of these average transactions in the state of Georgia could be required to comply with sales taxes in Georgia even though he or she had just over $16,000 in revenue.
This threshold, which theoretically should exempt small mom and pop companies, is affected by a loophole in some states. They’re counting gross revenue, not just taxable transactions. That means that a company with $200,000 in wholesale sales in Georgia and just $50,000 in direct to consumer sales could be surprised with a sales tax bill. Theoretically, in fact, just one taxable transaction could do it. If you are a manufacturer with a wholesale presence in a state and you sell a replacement part direct to one consumer, you could find yourself required to register and comply with sales tax regulations in that state.
In real life, Georgia isn’t going to send you a bill. They might send you an auditor, though. Once the new laws settle in, states can up their revenue significantly by going after companies with sales and use tax audits.
Still thinking about real life, it makes sense for companies with any direct to consumer sales to go ahead and register to collect sales tax in every state with any sales. It might be simplest to get set up now in every state, instead of complying one by one as the situation arises. Living in a constant state of emergency has costs.
Fortunately, SalesTaxDataLINK has sales tax services. We can take the entire issue off your shoulders and leave you free to focus on mission-critical tasks.
Call us to discuss your needs.
The Supreme Court decided in 2018 that states can requite remote sellers to collect and remit sales tax even when they don't have a physical presence in the state. Using "economic nexus," states can take their cut when manufacturers, retailers, and...read more
16 states started requiring sales tax compliance from online sellers this month. Florida is not one of them. In fact, Florida's attempt earlier this year to implement a new sales tax law failed. The Florida legislature plans to try again. At the moment,...read more
When the Supreme Court ruled that states have a right to make out of state sellers collect sales tax, one of the things that made them comfortable with the South Dakota law was its threshold. South Dakota said that remote sellers would have to collect...read more