California Considers Sales Tax Revolution
California is one of the sleeper states — the states that haven’t yet updated their sales tax regulations in response to Wayfair. Wayfair is the Supreme Court’s landmark 2018 decision overturning Quill and changing the definition of “nexus.” This decision allows states to make laws which compel remote sellers to collect and file sales tax even without physical nexus.
About half the 50 states have made those laws. California, however, has a different and much more radical idea. A new bill has been introduced in the legislature to study the idea of replacing sales taxes altogether with a carbon tax. Consumers would pay less for sustainable products and more for those that affect the environment more.
All products would be ranked on the basis of “carbon intensity,” the carbon footprint of the manufacture and presumably also the supply chain of the product. Sales and use taxes would be abolished, and consumers would instead pay a carbon tax based on the product’s carbon intensity.
The object of the new tax system would be to encourage consumers to choose more sustainable products. It would therefore be more like the “sin tax” on cigarettes and junk food than like an ordinary sales tax. Sales taxes are intended to raise revenue for the states and municipalities, more than to influence consumer behavior.
The carbon tax bill is not proposing an immediate change in taxes. Rather, it would start a study of the possible effects of making that change. If the carbon tax becomes law, there would be a five year transition period to figure it out.
Some of the issues that have already come up in discussions:
- Would the carbon tax hurt the state budget?
- Would prices overall rise or fall?
- Would the carbon tax affect manufacturers who already pay for carbon emissions in California?
- How would the carbon tax be calculated for products not made in California?
The calculation of the carbon tax might be an added responsibility for manufacturers. In the European Union, manufacturers are required to produce information on chemicals used in producing their goods. No data, no access to the market — it’s that simple.
California is the sixth largest market in the world, ahead of most nations. If California decides on a carbon tax, manufacturers may have to go along, just as they have had to go along with the EU’s chemical regulations.
a Luxury taxes are special sales taxes charged only on luxury goods, non-essential items that usually are expensive. In New York, for example, there's a luxury tax on the purchase of houses costing over $1,000,000. From 1991 to 1993 there was a "yacht...
a If you're looking into sales tax software options, don't forget to consider how you're going to get that software up and running. Just because you signed a contract and have the installation files in your possession doesn't mean you're ready to use...
a South Dakota is one of three states in the Union that charges the same sales tax rates for groceries as for other goods. Proposals to reduce or eliminate sales tax on groceries have come up in nearly every legislative session, including this year's,...